Yes, an existing cosmetic formula can absolutely be reformulated as vegan. The process involves identifying and replacing every animal-derived ingredient with a plant-based or synthetic alternative that delivers the same function. Most formulas can be successfully transitioned to vegan status, though the complexity of the reformulation depends on how many non-vegan ingredients are present and how central they are to the product’s performance.

Whether you are working with a moisturizer that contains beeswax, a shampoo built around keratin, or a serum using collagen, there is almost always a viable natural alternative available today. Below, we break down the key questions brands typically ask when exploring vegan cosmetics reformulation.

Which ingredients make a cosmetic formula non-vegan?

A cosmetic formula is non-vegan when it contains any ingredient derived from an animal or produced by an animal. Common examples include beeswax, honey, lanolin (from sheep’s wool), carmine (a red pigment from insects), collagen, keratin, casein (from milk), and squalane sourced from shark liver. These ingredients appear across haircare, skincare, and color cosmetics.

Some animal-derived ingredients are easy to spot on an INCI list, while others are less obvious. Stearic acid, for example, can come from either animal fat or plant sources depending on the supplier. Glycerin is another ingredient that is frequently animal-derived unless the formulator specifically sources a plant-based version. This is why a thorough ingredient audit is always the first step in any vegan reformulation project.

How does the reformulation process for vegan cosmetics work?

The vegan cosmetics reformulation process begins with a full ingredient audit to flag every component of animal origin. Each flagged ingredient is then matched to a plant-based or synthetic alternative that performs the same function. The reformulated product is tested for stability, efficacy, and sensory performance before it moves toward production.

In practice, the process typically follows these steps:

  1. Ingredient audit: Every raw material is reviewed against its source documentation to confirm whether it is animal-derived.
  2. Alternative selection: Plant-based or nature-identical substitutes are identified for each non-vegan ingredient, matched by function, texture, and compatibility.
  3. Prototype development: A new version of the formula is developed using the selected alternatives.
  4. Stability and performance testing: The reformulated product is tested to ensure it performs as expected over its intended shelf life.
  5. Regulatory review: The updated INCI list and any label claims are reviewed for compliance.

The timeline for this process varies depending on the formula’s complexity and how many ingredients need to be replaced. A product with one or two non-vegan components can often be reformulated relatively quickly, while a more complex formulation may require several rounds of testing.

Can plant-based alternatives match the performance of animal-derived ingredients?

In the vast majority of cases, yes. Plant-based alternatives have advanced significantly, and modern vegan cosmetic ingredients can match or even exceed the performance of their animal-derived counterparts. Carnauba wax and candelilla wax, for example, are highly effective substitutes for beeswax. Plant-derived squalane from sugarcane or olive oil performs comparably to shark-derived squalane. Hydrolyzed wheat or pea protein can replace keratin in many haircare applications.

The key is selecting the right alternative for the specific function the original ingredient was serving. A wax used for texture and structure requires a different replacement strategy than a wax used for film-forming or emollient properties. Working with an experienced formulator who understands the functional role of each ingredient makes a significant difference in the outcome.

Does reformulating as vegan affect product stability or shelf life?

Reformulating as vegan can affect stability and shelf life, but this is manageable with proper testing and formulation expertise. Animal-derived ingredients sometimes have unique structural or preservative properties, so switching to plant-based alternatives may require adjustments to the preservative system, emulsifier balance, or pH to maintain equivalent stability.

For example, beeswax contributes a specific crystalline structure to an emulsion that some plant-based waxes do not replicate exactly. A formulator may need to combine two or three plant-based waxes to achieve the same texture and stability profile. This kind of fine-tuning is a normal part of the reformulation process and is why stability testing after reformulation is non-negotiable before a product goes to market.

What certifications are needed after a vegan reformulation?

After a vegan reformulation, brands typically pursue third-party vegan certification to substantiate their claim on packaging and marketing materials. The most recognized certifications in the European market include the Vegan Society’s Vegan Trademark and the EVE VEGAN certification. These require documentation proving that no animal-derived ingredients or processing aids were used.

Beyond vegan certification, brands should also consider whether their reformulated product still meets existing certifications it held before, such as organic or natural cosmetics standards (COSMOS, for example). A reformulation can sometimes affect compliance with these standards if the replacement ingredients do not meet the same sourcing or processing criteria. It is worth reviewing all active certifications as part of the reformulation process, not just the vegan claim.

When should a brand consider a full reformulation versus a new formula?

A full reformulation of an existing product makes sense when the brand has established equity in that product and wants to retain its identity, packaging, and consumer recognition while updating its ingredient profile. If the core structure of the formula remains sound and only a handful of ingredients need replacing, reformulation is almost always the more efficient path than starting from scratch.

A new formula is worth considering when the existing product has fundamental formulation challenges beyond its non-vegan ingredients, when the brand wants to significantly change the product’s texture, performance profile, or positioning, or when the cost of reformulating a highly complex formula approaches the cost of developing something new. In practice, most brands benefit from reformulation when the goal is simply to make an existing product vegan, while new development suits a broader product evolution.

How Rebel Nature helps with vegan cosmetics reformulation

At Rebel Nature, we specialize in exactly this kind of work. As a natural cosmetics contract manufacturer with over a decade of experience in plant-based formulation, we have the expertise and raw material library to guide brands through every stage of a vegan reformulation. Here is what working with us looks like in practice:

  • Thorough ingredient audits to identify every animal-derived component in your existing formula
  • Access to over 500 natural raw materials, giving us a wide selection of high-quality, ethically sourced plant-based alternatives
  • In-house stability and performance testing to ensure your reformulated product meets the same standards as the original
  • Guidance on certification pathways, so your vegan claim is properly substantiated
  • Flexible production for both small and large order volumes, making reformulation accessible regardless of where you are in your brand journey

We work closely with each brand throughout the process, offering ingredient recommendations and transparent collaboration at every step. If you are ready to make your formula vegan or simply want to explore what is possible, get in touch with us and let us find the right path forward together.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a vegan cosmetics reformulation typically take from start to finish?

The timeline depends heavily on the complexity of the existing formula and the number of ingredients that need replacing. A straightforward reformulation with one or two non-vegan ingredients can be completed in as little as 6 to 12 weeks, while a more complex product requiring multiple replacements and several rounds of stability testing may take 4 to 6 months or longer. Building in enough time for proper stability testing is essential and should not be rushed, as this is what protects your product’s performance and shelf life after launch.

Will my product need to be re-registered or re-approved by regulators after a vegan reformulation?

In most markets, including the EU, any change to a cosmetic formula’s ingredient list requires updating the product’s safety documentation and, where applicable, notifying the relevant regulatory portal — such as the EU Cosmetic Products Notification Portal (CPNP). A reformulation may also trigger the need for a new safety assessment by a qualified cosmetic safety assessor, particularly if the replacement ingredients differ significantly from the originals. It is important to factor regulatory review into your reformulation timeline and budget from the outset.

What is the most challenging animal-derived ingredient to replace in a cosmetic formula?

Beeswax and lanolin are among the most technically challenging to replace because they contribute very specific structural, emulsifying, and sensory properties that no single plant-based ingredient replicates exactly. Carmine, the red pigment derived from insects, can also be difficult to substitute in color cosmetics because many plant-based red colorants have lower stability or a different color payoff. However, none of these are insurmountable — experienced formulators typically address them by blending two or more plant-based alternatives to replicate the functional profile of the original ingredient.

Does switching to a vegan formula mean the product will also be cruelty-free?

Not automatically. Vegan and cruelty-free are related but distinct claims. A vegan product contains no animal-derived ingredients, while a cruelty-free product has not been tested on animals at any stage of development or production. It is entirely possible for a vegan formula to be tested on animals, and equally possible for a non-vegan formula to be cruelty-free. If your brand wants to make both claims, you will need to address ingredient sourcing (vegan) and testing practices (cruelty-free) separately, and pursue the relevant certifications for each.

Can I market my product as vegan without a formal third-party certification?

Technically yes, but it carries risk. Without third-party certification, your vegan claim is self-declared and relies entirely on your own documentation and supply chain verification. This leaves the brand exposed to scrutiny from consumers, retailers, and regulatory bodies if the claim is ever challenged. Third-party certification from recognized bodies such as The Vegan Society or EVE VEGAN provides independent verification, strengthens consumer trust, and is increasingly expected by major retailers and distributors — making it a worthwhile investment for any brand serious about its vegan positioning.

Will a vegan reformulation significantly increase my production costs?

It depends on the specific ingredients being replaced. Some plant-based alternatives are cost-neutral or even less expensive than their animal-derived counterparts, while others — such as certain specialty waxes or high-purity plant-derived actives — may carry a higher price point. In some cases, blending two or three plant-based ingredients to replicate a single animal-derived one can also add to raw material costs. That said, many brands find that the commercial upside of a credible vegan positioning — broader retailer access, stronger consumer appeal, and alignment with growing market demand — more than justifies any incremental cost increase.

What should I do if I am unsure whether my current formula contains any animal-derived ingredients?

The best starting point is to request full source documentation from each of your raw material suppliers, specifically asking them to confirm the origin of every ingredient and any processing aids used. Pay particular attention to ingredients like glycerin, stearic acid, and certain emulsifiers, which are commonly animal-derived unless explicitly stated otherwise. If you are unsure how to interpret the documentation or where to look, working with an experienced contract manufacturer or formulation specialist who can conduct a formal ingredient audit is the most reliable way to get a clear and complete picture before committing to a vegan claim.