Not all cosmetic pigments are vegan. Some of the most widely used colorants in makeup and personal care products come from animal sources, including insects, beetles, and fish scales. Whether a pigment is vegan depends entirely on its origin and how it was produced, so checking ingredient labels carefully is essential for anyone following a vegan lifestyle.

The good news is that vegan alternatives exist for virtually every animal-derived pigment used in cosmetics today. Below, we break down the key questions around vegan cosmetic pigments so you can make more informed choices.

Which cosmetic pigments are not vegan?

Several commonly used cosmetic pigments are derived from animals. The most well-known is carmine, also called cochineal or CI 75470, which is made by crushing dried female cochineal insects. Guanine, sourced from fish scales, is used to create the shimmer effect in highlighters and nail polishes. Shellac, derived from the secretions of lac bugs, occasionally appears in cosmetics as a coating or binder.

These animal-derived pigments appear across a wide range of products, including lipsticks, eyeshadows, blushers, and foundations. Carmine in particular is extremely prevalent because it produces a vivid, stable red that is difficult to replicate with plant-based sources. Many consumers are surprised to find it listed under alternative names such as natural red 4, E120, or cochineal extract, which makes identification more challenging.

What makes a cosmetic pigment vegan?

A cosmetic pigment is considered vegan when it contains no ingredients sourced from animals or animal by-products, and when no animals were harmed or used in its production. This includes both the pigment itself and any carrier or processing agents used during its manufacture.

Vegan cosmetic pigments typically fall into one of three categories:

  • Mineral pigments: Iron oxides, titanium dioxide, and ultramarines are inorganic colorants mined or synthetically produced without any animal involvement.
  • Synthetic organic pigments: Lab-created colorants that mimic the properties of natural dyes without relying on animal sources.
  • Plant-derived pigments: Colorants extracted from fruits, vegetables, roots, and flowers, such as beetroot red or spirulina blue.

It is also worth noting that vegan does not automatically mean cruelty-free. A pigment can be free of animal ingredients but still be tested on animals. For a product to be both vegan and cruelty-free, neither the ingredients nor the finished formula should involve animal testing.

Are natural and vegan the same thing in cosmetic pigments?

Natural and vegan are not the same thing when it comes to cosmetic pigments. A pigment can be entirely natural in origin and still not be vegan. Carmine is a perfect example: it is a naturally derived colorant, but it comes from insects, making it non-vegan.

Conversely, some synthetic pigments are vegan even though they are not natural. Many lab-created colorants contain no animal ingredients whatsoever and are therefore suitable for vegan formulations. The distinction matters because consumers often assume that “natural” implies vegan-friendly, which is not always the case.

When evaluating cosmetic colorants, it is more useful to ask about the source of the ingredient rather than whether it is natural or synthetic. The origin, not the processing method, determines whether a pigment qualifies as vegan.

How can you tell if a pigment in your cosmetic is vegan?

To determine whether a pigment in your cosmetic product is vegan, start by reading the full ingredient list and looking for known animal-derived colorants. The most important ones to watch for are carmine (listed as CI 75470, cochineal, natural red 4, or E120) and guanine (listed as CI 75170 or pearl essence).

Beyond reading labels, these steps can help:

  1. Look for certified vegan logos on the packaging, such as the Vegan Society trademark or Leaping Bunny certification.
  2. Check the brand’s website for a dedicated vegan product list or ingredient transparency policy.
  3. Contact the brand directly if you are unsure about a specific ingredient or product.
  4. Use ingredient checker tools or apps designed to flag animal-derived cosmetic ingredients.

Keep in mind that ingredient lists can be long and technical. Familiarizing yourself with the INCI names of common animal-derived pigments makes the process considerably easier over time.

What vegan alternatives exist for animal-derived pigments?

Vegan alternatives exist for all major animal-derived cosmetic pigments, and many of them perform just as well in modern formulations. The cosmetics industry has made significant progress in developing plant-based and mineral substitutes that match the color intensity and stability of their animal-derived counterparts.

Alternatives to carmine

Carmine is the most commonly replaced animal-derived pigment. Effective vegan substitutes include:

  • Beetroot extract: Produces natural pink and red tones, though it can be less stable under heat and light.
  • Radish anthocyanins: Offer a range of red and purple hues with good color payoff.
  • Synthetic carmine alternatives: Lab-created versions that replicate carmine’s hue without using insects.
  • Iron oxides: Mineral-based pigments that can be blended to achieve warm red and terracotta shades.

Alternatives to guanine

The shimmer and iridescence that guanine provides can be replicated using:

  • Mica: A naturally occurring mineral that creates a similar pearlescent effect.
  • Synthetic fluorphlogopite: A lab-created mica alternative with a consistent shimmer finish.
  • Bismuth oxychloride: A mineral compound that delivers a bright, lustrous sheen.

As demand for vegan makeup ingredients continues to grow, formulators are investing more in developing stable, high-performing plant and mineral pigments. The range of available options is broader than ever, making it increasingly straightforward to create fully vegan color cosmetics without compromising on quality.

How Rebel Nature helps with vegan cosmetic pigments

At Rebel Nature, we work exclusively with natural ingredients, and that commitment extends fully to the pigments and colorants we use in our formulations. Whether you are developing a vegan lipstick, a mineral foundation, or a tinted skincare product, we help you navigate the world of cosmetic colorants with confidence.

Here is what we bring to the table:

  • Access to an extensive portfolio of over 500 raw materials, including a wide range of vegan-certified pigments and colorants
  • Expert guidance on replacing animal-derived pigments such as carmine or guanine with high-performing vegan alternatives
  • Formulation support tailored to your product category, color goals, and sustainability requirements
  • Transparent ingredient sourcing so you can communicate your vegan credentials clearly to your customers
  • Flexible production for both small and large order volumes, making vegan formulation accessible at any stage of your brand’s growth

If you are ready to develop a vegan cosmetic product or want to reformulate an existing product to remove animal-derived pigments, get in touch with our team. We would love to help you bring your vision to life. You can also learn more about how we work to get a better sense of what collaborating with us looks like.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a cosmetic product be labelled vegan if it contains synthetic pigments that were tested on animals?

No — a product cannot be genuinely considered vegan if animal testing was involved at any stage, even if all the ingredients themselves are animal-free. True vegan cosmetics must satisfy two conditions: no animal-derived ingredients and no animal testing of either the individual ingredients or the finished formula. Always look for both a vegan certification and a cruelty-free certification (such as Leaping Bunny) to be confident on both counts.

Are mineral pigments like iron oxides and mica always vegan?

Mineral pigments such as iron oxides, titanium dioxide, and ultramarines are inherently vegan because they are mined or synthetically produced without any animal involvement. Mica, however, comes with an important caveat: while the mineral itself is vegan, its supply chain has historically been linked to unethical mining practices. If ethical sourcing matters to your brand, opt for suppliers who use responsibly sourced or synthetic mica (fluorphlogopite) and can provide full supply chain transparency.

How stable are plant-derived vegan pigments compared to carmine in cosmetic formulations?

This is one of the most common formulation challenges when switching away from carmine. Plant-derived pigments such as beetroot extract and anthocyanins can be less stable under heat, light, and varying pH levels, which may affect shelf life and colour consistency. However, modern encapsulation techniques and stabilising agents have significantly improved their performance. Working with an experienced formulator who knows how to optimise these ingredients is key to achieving a stable, long-lasting result.

What is the best way to get started if I want to reformulate an existing product to remove animal-derived pigments?

Start by auditing your current ingredient list to identify every animal-derived colorant — paying close attention to alternative names for carmine and guanine. Once identified, work with a formulation partner to test vegan alternatives that match your target colour, texture, and performance profile. It is advisable to run stability tests and consumer trials on the reformulated product before relaunching, as swapping pigments can affect shade, payoff, and longevity.

Do vegan cosmetic pigments cost more than animal-derived ones?

The cost varies depending on the specific pigment and its source. Mineral pigments like iron oxides are generally very cost-competitive, while high-quality plant-derived extracts or certified synthetic alternatives can carry a higher price tag. That said, as demand for vegan ingredients grows, costs are becoming more competitive across the board. Factoring in the marketing value of a verified vegan product — which commands strong consumer loyalty in today’s market — often makes the investment well worthwhile.

Are there any common mistakes brands make when claiming their products are vegan?

One of the most frequent mistakes is overlooking hidden animal-derived ingredients in non-pigment components of the formula — for example, beeswax in a lipstick base or lanolin in a moisturising tint. Another common error is relying solely on a supplier’s verbal assurance rather than requesting written documentation or third-party certification. To make a credible vegan claim, every ingredient in the formula — including carriers, binders, and preservatives — must be verified, not just the pigments.

Which vegan certifications should I look for when sourcing pigments for a vegan cosmetic line?

The most widely recognised certifications for vegan cosmetic ingredients include the Vegan Society trademark and COSMOS certification (for natural and organic formulations). For cruelty-free assurance, the Leaping Bunny programme is the gold standard. When sourcing pigments specifically, ask suppliers for ingredient-level vegan certification documentation rather than relying only on product-level claims, as this gives you a much stronger foundation for your own brand’s vegan credentials.